Courts' diversion program under fire

The judicial diversion program, which offers an alternative to prison time for convicted criminals, is coming under fire in the wake of an NYPD officer's fatal shooting. Tyrone Howard, the man accused

News 12 Staff

Oct 23, 2015, 2:13 AM

Updated 3,106 days ago

Share:

Courts' diversion program under fire
The judicial diversion program, which offers an alternative to prison time for convicted criminals, is coming under fire in the wake of an NYPD officer's fatal shooting.
Tyrone Howard, the man accused of shooting Officer Randolph Holder in the head earlier this week, was placed into the diversion system by a judge last year.
Police say Howard had a rap sheet that included 18 prior arrests. Commissioner Bill Bratton says he should have been put in prison.
"His whole life has been an escalation of crime and criminal activity," Bratton says of Howard.
The judge ordered Howard into the diversion program after an arrest for allegedly selling crack-cocaine last year.
Criminal defense attorney Renee Hill says Howard appeared to fit the criteria for a diversion program at the time.
"It's given to offenders who do not have a prior violent history," Hill says.
Of Howard's 18 prior arrests, police say all of them were drug-related except for a shooting arrest in 2009 in which the charges were dropped.
Experts say that because he was not prosecuted in connection with the shooting charge, it could not be held against him when considering his eligibility for diversion.
Diversion offers addiction treatment and counseling for offenders. It also includes random drug tests.
It's currently only up to a judge to decide who goes into such programs, but Bratton says the NYPD should have input as well. Both the commissioner and Mayor Bill de Blasio have called for increased scrutiny of the practice.


More from News 12
2:31
NYPD: Fordham shooting kills 33-year-old man, leaves another man critical

NYPD: Fordham shooting kills 33-year-old man, leaves another man critical

1:56
Early morning showers lead to sun, clouds and breezy conditions for NYC

Early morning showers lead to sun, clouds and breezy conditions for NYC

1:04
DOT adds $6 million to boost overnight and evening deliveries over peak hours

DOT adds $6 million to boost overnight and evening deliveries over peak hours

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

0:20
MTA service alerts system now includes bridges, tunnels

MTA service alerts system now includes bridges, tunnels

0:23
Police: 2 men wanted for robbing Gamestop store at knifepoint in East Tremont

Police: 2 men wanted for robbing Gamestop store at knifepoint in East Tremont

0:24
NYPD: Suspect at large in West Concourse stabbing that left victim in grave condition

NYPD: Suspect at large in West Concourse stabbing that left victim in grave condition

2:07
Two NYPD officers arrested and facing multiple charges of sexual assault

Two NYPD officers arrested and facing multiple charges of sexual assault

1:57
Security heightened at Bronx Home Depot following customer complaints of uncomfortable encounters

Security heightened at Bronx Home Depot following customer complaints of uncomfortable encounters

DA: 3 teens indicted for killing bystander, wounding 4 in subway shooting

DA: 3 teens indicted for killing bystander, wounding 4 in subway shooting

1:53
Bronx bookworms take part in writing workshop for World Book Day

Bronx bookworms take part in writing workshop for World Book Day

1:57
State taxi federation raises reward for information to help stop carjackings, robberies

State taxi federation raises reward for information to help stop carjackings, robberies

1:42
Irish consulate general joins BP Gibson for a Woodlawn walkthrough

Irish consulate general joins BP Gibson for a Woodlawn walkthrough

1:00
Fordham Road BID discusses local improvements made, offers a look toward the future

Fordham Road BID discusses local improvements made, offers a look toward the future

1:56
MTA meets with riders in Fordham to hear their concerns with current transit system

MTA meets with riders in Fordham to hear their concerns with current transit system

0:59
City now has power to padlock illegal cannabis stores

City now has power to padlock illegal cannabis stores

1:30
NYPD: Shooting suspect linked to death of 24-year-old in Melrose still on the loose

NYPD: Shooting suspect linked to death of 24-year-old in Melrose still on the loose

0:30
Bronx hip-hop star MC Sha-Rock, Bronx Historical Society offering $1,000 scholarship

Bronx hip-hop star MC Sha-Rock, Bronx Historical Society offering $1,000 scholarship

1:44
'I can sleep better.' Longwood resident thanks News 12 for report on Bruckner Expressway construction noise

'I can sleep better.' Longwood resident thanks News 12 for report on Bruckner Expressway construction noise