Attorney pursues new defense for ex-animal rescue president accused of starving dogs

The attorney for a former animal rescue president accused of starving to death five dogs in her Fairfield home has disclosed he's pursuing a new defense in the case.

News 12 Staff

Jul 15, 2019, 9:11 PM

Updated 1,743 days ago

Share:

The attorney for a former animal rescue president accused of starving to death five dogs in her Fairfield home has disclosed he's pursuing a new defense in the case.
Monday was supposed to be a deadline for Heidi Lueders to produce proof explaining why she previously had prescription drugs in her system. The judge on Monday gave her a couple more days to do so.
Lueders' attorney told the court he's reversing course, and abandoning an initial defense based on mental illness.
"However, they do want to explore a defense related to her abuse of drugs as being a factor in forming her intent or lack of intent to commit a crime," says Ken Bernhard, the attorney appointed to represent the victims in the case - now known as the Fairfield Five.

In November, police responded to Lueders' home and discovered the dogs dead - each in a cage, reduced to just bones. They also found mounds of trash, feces and drug paraphernalia throughout the home.

Lueders faces five counts of felony animal cruelty. As part of her bail, she's subject to random drug tests.

She previously tested positive for prescriptions that she says a doctor gave her to help with withdrawal. Lueders was supposed to provide a letter to the judge proving that Monday.
“She failed to do that. The judge gave defense counsel until Wednesday to produce such a letter to validate that the prescriptions she's taking and the drugs that are in her system are in fact lawfully secured in being used,” says Bernhard.
If Lueders doesn't produce a letter by Wednesday, the judge wants a hearing Friday morning where she will likely face consequences.


More from News 12
1:30
NYPD: Shooting suspect linked to death of 24-year-old in Melrose still on the loose

NYPD: Shooting suspect linked to death of 24-year-old in Melrose still on the loose

0:30
Bronx hip-hop star MC Sha-Rock, Bronx Historical Society offering $1,000 scholarship

Bronx hip-hop star MC Sha-Rock, Bronx Historical Society offering $1,000 scholarship

1:49
Another spring-tastic day for NYC; tracking spotty showers into Wednesday

Another spring-tastic day for NYC; tracking spotty showers into Wednesday

1:44
'I can sleep better.' Longwood resident thanks News 12 for report on Bruckner Expressway construction noise

'I can sleep better.' Longwood resident thanks News 12 for report on Bruckner Expressway construction noise

0:27
Police: $1,000 stolen from Bronx gas station at gunpoint; suspects at large

Police: $1,000 stolen from Bronx gas station at gunpoint; suspects at large

State police: Victim of I-684 car crash identified as convicted murderer in country illegally

State police: Victim of I-684 car crash identified as convicted murderer in country illegally

2:50
Residents in Morris Heights living in ‘uninhabitable’ conditions demand fair housing

Residents in Morris Heights living in ‘uninhabitable’ conditions demand fair housing

1:34
'We really want to find him.' Wakefield family searches for missing loved one

'We really want to find him.' Wakefield family searches for missing loved one

0:45
New York Botanical Garden celebrates Earth Day

New York Botanical Garden celebrates Earth Day

1:27
Scholar Athlete: Tiarra Jackson

Scholar Athlete: Tiarra Jackson

1:49
Spring break in the Bronx: Low-cost events and activities around the borough

Spring break in the Bronx: Low-cost events and activities around the borough

1:43
Jamie Towers residents rally against increased rent, citing unsanitary conditions

Jamie Towers residents rally against increased rent, citing unsanitary conditions

0:27
Sanitation workers to collect trash earlier to speed up cleaning NYC streets

Sanitation workers to collect trash earlier to speed up cleaning NYC streets

0:30
Police: Bronx commuter wanted for spraying MTA employee in the face with 'an unknown substance'

Police: Bronx commuter wanted for spraying MTA employee in the face with 'an unknown substance'

1:40
Bronx's Oyate Group, Grubhub and NYS Latino Restaurant Association team up for restaurant business boost

Bronx's Oyate Group, Grubhub and NYS Latino Restaurant Association team up for restaurant business boost

1:44
Estella Diggs honored with street sign unveiling in Morrisania

Estella Diggs honored with street sign unveiling in Morrisania

0:36
Yonkers native Mary J. Blige, Queens hip-hop group A Tribe Called Quest selected for Rock Hall of Fame

Yonkers native Mary J. Blige, Queens hip-hop group A Tribe Called Quest selected for Rock Hall of Fame

0:59
NYPD: Suspect wanted for shooting 18-year-old in Belmont

NYPD: Suspect wanted for shooting 18-year-old in Belmont

1:56
Passover preparation underway for members of Chabad Lubavitch of Riverdale

Passover preparation underway for members of Chabad Lubavitch of Riverdale