News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
NYC Politics
Rebuilding The Bronx

Judge dismisses Rockland election results lawsuit seeking recount of 2024 results

State Supreme Court Judge Rachel Tanguay has dismissed a lawsuit filed by SMART Legislation that was seeking a hand recount in 2024 presidential and U.S. Senate election results in Rockland County.

Diane Caruso

Dec 16, 2025, 5:14 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

State Supreme Court Judge Rachel Tanguay dismissed a lawsuit filed by SMART Legislation that was seeking a hand recount in 2024 presidential and U.S. Senate election results in Rockland County.

Judge Tanguay's decision stated they "lacked standing" and other legal requirements.

In a statement to News 12, Rockland's Board of Elections says they plan to "continue to administer and certify election results in accordance with all applicable laws and procedures.”

"We consider this a victory, even though we didn't get a hand count. We got a tremendous amount of information in discovery," said Lulu Friesdat, with SMART Legislation.

She adds they learned about the way passwords to voting machines are handled, received conflicting information, among other things.

Friesdat says they are glad they brought the lawsuit,

"We want to emphasize the case was not dismissed on its merits," said Friesdat.

One of SMART Legislation's claims involved a third-party candidate for New York's U.S. Senate seat. Rockland resident Diane Sare had sworn affidavits from more voters than what is reflected in the result totals for two districts.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:57
JONBXE147FIRE6226_2026-06-02-05-18-02

Nearly 80 firefighters battle flames on building's rooftop in Mott Haven

FIFA World Cup

NYC launches Neighborhood Passport program ahead of FIFA

01:25
CX Headlines 4 (37)

Comfortable this afternoon before summer heat surges into The Bronx by the end of the week

02:01
REBUILDINGJODI6226_2026-06-02-05-33-00

Fixed-income homeowner saves thousands through housing program

01:44
FULTONAVESHOOTINGTHUMB

Source: Morrisania shooting that wounded 69-year-old man stemmed from weekend argument

Screenshot 2026-06-02 122543

MTA transforms Knicks-themed subway station ahead of NBA finals

01:47
hurricane(stormwatchlook) copy

2026 hurricane season now underway. Here’s what to expect.

00:32
14yoshotsuspect

Police identify man wanted for shooting 14-year-old boy in broad daylight in Allerton

00:26
52 Precinct - Menacing (RMA 1340-26) Inidividual Photos

Man displays knife to MTA bus driver in Norwood

02:19
RTBXBKFundingFDNYSIsrael10pm_2026-06-01-22-22-46

‘If only they had a 5th firefighter.’ Bronx families, city leaders push for FDNY staffing increase

01:21
BX5PMLINDSAYLONGWOOD_2026-06-01-17-06-41

Man shot in foot, cars struck in Longwood shooting

01:42
RTBXChurchBurglaryNHernandez5pm_2026-06-01-17-20-52

Church burglar on the run in Kingsbridge Heights

02:29
BXKLN5PMHEATHERNYPD_2026-06-01-17-18-49

NYPD expected to spend $92M in overtime during NBA finals, FIFA World Cup, America 250

01:26
RTBKMysteryPeopleSewerFoloMelissaRCooper5pm_2026-06-01-17-21-32

Questions remain after group seen emerging from Brooklyn sewer system

01:06
Scot Pollard

‘We didn't ask for this.’ NBA champion Scot Pollard gets advanced heart transplant testing done by Yale School of Medicine

01:23
BXE213THST6126_2026-06-01-05-08-53

Police search for gunman who shot a man in the leg in Williamsbridge

00:19
AP26152638861877

Giants add receivers Odell Beckham Jr., JuJu Smith-Schuster and returner Braxton Berrios

00:49
HOMEPROGRAMFREE6126_2026-06-01-12-34-15

NYC launches ‘no-penalty’ inspection program for homeowners

00:56
BXKNICKSFINALMAM6126_2026-06-01-12-34-18

Mamdani signs order repealing bedtimes for Knicks Finals run

01:47
BXWESBTERNOISE6126_2026-06-01-05-31-07

'Let people sleep.' Norwood musician says decade of late-night noise is disrupting her life and music

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices