Soap or sanitizer: Which is better?

Disinfecting your hands with soap and sanitizer is critical to prevent the spread of coronavirus, but is one better than the other?

News 12 Staff

Mar 15, 2020, 11:54 AM

Updated 1,527 days ago

Share:

Text by Geoff Bansen, Video by Michelle Divon:
Hand sanitizer and hand washing have been all over the headlines for a week now. In times like these, they are common sense. But is one better than the other?
Yes, says Andrea Love, Immunologist and Microbiologist from Vital Statistics Consulting.
"The coronavirus has a lipid and protein-based envelope that surrounds and protects the virus from having its RNA degraded. This envelope is exactly what it sounds like - a fatty coating. Soap is a detergent, and one property of that is it is able to disrupt fat molecules and disperse them. This is why soap and other detergents clean your greasy stove so well. So, in the case of COVID-19, what happens when soap interacts with this fat-enveloped virus? Exactly the same thing. The soap that you wash your hands with disrupts the virus’ protective coating and demolishes it. It also will dislodge any attached viral particles and wash them down the drain. This is why regular old soap is the best practice!” says Love.
But what makes this different from hand sanitizer?
"Sanitizer doesn't actually clean your hands, which isn't ideal. But it's also OK if you aren't able to get to a sink," says Love.
Photos: Impact from around the world
undefined
 


More from News 12
1:19
Police: 1 man dead, another injured in Edenwald double shooting

Police: 1 man dead, another injured in Edenwald double shooting

1:44
Sun and clouds with July-like temperatures for NYC this week

Sun and clouds with July-like temperatures for NYC this week

1:30
Madison Square Boys & Girls Club alumni fight to find a buyer following closing announcement of Crotona Park location

Madison Square Boys & Girls Club alumni fight to find a buyer following closing announcement of Crotona Park location

1:43
‘Ride of Silence’ takes cyclists on ghost bike tour, honors victims of traffic accidents

‘Ride of Silence’ takes cyclists on ghost bike tour, honors victims of traffic accidents

1:00
FDNY firefighter injured during Bronx house fire released from hospital

FDNY firefighter injured during Bronx house fire released from hospital

1:42
Bronx Week: Festivities wrap up with parade and food festival

Bronx Week: Festivities wrap up with parade and food festival

0:51
FDNY responds to 2 overnight fires in the Bronx; 2 injured

FDNY responds to 2 overnight fires in the Bronx; 2 injured

1:52
FDNY: Portion of roof collapses onto sidewalk in Williamsburg

FDNY: Portion of roof collapses onto sidewalk in Williamsburg

1:39
NYPD: 2 armed robberies involving mopeds in Brooklyn believed to be connected

NYPD: 2 armed robberies involving mopeds in Brooklyn believed to be connected

1:45
 Missed swim lessons due to COVID-19 may be contributing to rise in child drownings

Missed swim lessons due to COVID-19 may be contributing to rise in child drownings

1:58
Brooklyn residents say there is an urgent need for more birth options in NYC

Brooklyn residents say there is an urgent need for more birth options in NYC

0:23
NYPD: Bullet grazes woman in Soundview; 3 suspects wanted for shooting

NYPD: Bullet grazes woman in Soundview; 3 suspects wanted for shooting

1:50
Al Quiñones Playground: Park renamed in honor of Longwood community activist

Al Quiñones Playground: Park renamed in honor of Longwood community activist

1:47
NYPD: 30-year-old man fatally shot, another injured in Brownsville

NYPD: 30-year-old man fatally shot, another injured in Brownsville

0:17
Authorities: George Washington Bridge climber in custody

Authorities: George Washington Bridge climber in custody

1:38
Cyclists pedal through Brooklyn during Haitian Flag Day Ride & Fête

Cyclists pedal through Brooklyn during Haitian Flag Day Ride & Fête

0:29
Grandparents Around the World hosts 14th annual Grandparents Ball

Grandparents Around the World hosts 14th annual Grandparents Ball

1:46
Somber ceremony in Bissel Garden reflects on the impacts, lives lost during COVID-19 pandemic

Somber ceremony in Bissel Garden reflects on the impacts, lives lost during COVID-19 pandemic

1:43
CDC urges people to get vaccinated amid resurgence of mpox

CDC urges people to get vaccinated amid resurgence of mpox

1:41
Andrea Navedo, Antwan ‘Amadeus’ Thompson among inductees into Bronx Walk of Fame

Andrea Navedo, Antwan ‘Amadeus’ Thompson among inductees into Bronx Walk of Fame