Closing arguments delivered in NYPD sergeant's murder trial

<p>Closing arguments were delivered Wednesday in the murder trial against an NYPD sergeant.</p>

News 12 Staff

Feb 15, 2018, 12:09 AM

Updated 2,274 days ago

Share:

Closing arguments were delivered Wednesday in the murder trial against an NYPD sergeant.
Sgt. Hugh Barry is charged with second-degree murder, manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide in the Oct. 18, 2016 death of Deborah Danner.
Barry took the stand in his own defense Tuesday, testifying that he shot Danner because she was about to swing a bat at his head. The 66-year-old Danner was emotionally disturbed, and advocates argue that Barry did not follow proper protocol when responding to her Pugsley Avenue apartment in the Bronx.
On Wednesday, Barry's attorney worked to disprove and weaken the argument of the prosecution by saying Barry followed his training and the protocol put in place by the NYPD. He went on to say that Danner cannot be seen as an emotionally disturbed person because the moment she grabbed the bat, she become a person with a weapon. He said his client was clearly acting in self-defense, adding that the district attorney's argument is based on what would have happened.
The prosecution came out strong against inconsistencies they saw in Barry's testimony on Tuesday -- like how close Barry was to Danner at the time of the shooting and whether she actually swung the bat, which they believe would prove if Barry was in fact in imminent danger. They added that Barry was the only officer to draw his weapon, while a nearby officer and others in the room chose not to do so.
Bronx Supreme Court Judge Robert Neary is expected to issue his verdict Thursday morning. If convicted, Barry faces a maximum sentence of 25 years to life in prison.
Barry is the first on-duty NYPD officer to be charged with murder since 1999.


More from News 12
0:31
Member of Trinitarios gang sentenced to life for murder of Bronx man on Long Island

Member of Trinitarios gang sentenced to life for murder of Bronx man on Long Island

2:04
STORM WATCH: Tracking strong thundershowers for Wednesday and Thursday in NYC

STORM WATCH: Tracking strong thundershowers for Wednesday and Thursday in NYC

1:47
Bronx Community College over the moon about newest tree planted on campus

Bronx Community College over the moon about newest tree planted on campus

2:03
Bronx County Fair comes to Throggs Neck

Bronx County Fair comes to Throggs Neck

2:14
DSNY clears trash left by homeless encampment in Kingsbridge Heights after multiple complaints

DSNY clears trash left by homeless encampment in Kingsbridge Heights after multiple complaints

0:25
MTA announces new strategy to improve transit infrastructure for B and D train lines

MTA announces new strategy to improve transit infrastructure for B and D train lines

1:41
Gov. Kathy Hochul regrets saying Black kids in the Bronx don't know what a computer is

Gov. Kathy Hochul regrets saying Black kids in the Bronx don't know what a computer is

1:52
UFT: More than 850 Title I schools have the space to meet NY’s class size law

UFT: More than 850 Title I schools have the space to meet NY’s class size law

0:24
Police: 37-year-old man found dead inside Soundview home

Police: 37-year-old man found dead inside Soundview home

0:26
Officials identify 29-year-old suspect linked to fire in Allerton building

Officials identify 29-year-old suspect linked to fire in Allerton building

0:27
Authorities: 3 men wanted for stealing $300, pizza from delivery driver in the Bronx

Authorities: 3 men wanted for stealing $300, pizza from delivery driver in the Bronx

0:50
Jennifer Lopez, Cardi B. show off their style at the Met Gala 2024 event

Jennifer Lopez, Cardi B. show off their style at the Met Gala 2024 event

Discounts and perks teachers can use all year

Discounts and perks teachers can use all year

0:29
Attorney General James sues local clinics for abortion-reversal claims

Attorney General James sues local clinics for abortion-reversal claims

0:39
 ‘Melanie’s Law’ passes state Senate, heads for final approval

‘Melanie’s Law’ passes state Senate, heads for final approval

Guide: Deals and freebies for health care workers

Guide: Deals and freebies for health care workers

1:46
Bronx leaders respond to Gov. Hochul's controversial comment on Black and brown kids in the borough

Bronx leaders respond to Gov. Hochul's controversial comment on Black and brown kids in the borough

1:35
City program may help restaurants with outdoor dining reimagine space, provide resources

City program may help restaurants with outdoor dining reimagine space, provide resources

2:16
Bronx businesses say they’re losing money because of local homeless encampments

Bronx businesses say they’re losing money because of local homeless encampments

2:05
Business improvement districts honored for helping small businesses

Business improvement districts honored for helping small businesses