NYPD commissioner defends releasing footage of deadly shooting

<p>NYPD Commissioner James O'Neill is defending the decision to publicly release the body camera footage from a deadly police-involved shooting in the Bronx.</p>

News 12 Staff

Sep 15, 2017, 9:48 PM

Updated 2,420 days ago

Share:

NYPD Commissioner James O'Neill is defending the decision to publicly release the body camera footage from a deadly police-involved shooting in the Bronx.
The decision received from pushback from the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, which said the move violates officers' rights. O'Neill said he knows what it's like being an officer, but felt that it was important to show the video to the public.
Four different officers from the 47th Precinct recorded the incident, which authorities released stitched together in a 16-minute video. It shows officers responding to a wellness check in the Edenwald section of the Bronx. The officers can be heard numerous times telling 31-year-old Miguel Richards to drop his weapons, a knife and what turned out to be a fake gun.
When Richards raised the imitation gun in the direction of the officers, police say that's when one officer fired a stun gun and the other two fired their service weapons, killing Richards.
This is the first time the NYPD has released body camera footage of a deadly police-involved shooting.
"I think it is to build a trust within this great city, to increase our transparency, but also to let people know what our police officers face each and every day," O'Neill said of releasing the footage.
The officers involved have been identified as Mark Flemming and Redmond Murphy, who both fired their service weapons, and officers Jesus Ramos and Marco Oliveras, who showed up later.
Go here to watch the bodycam video. (WARNING: Graphic content)
The New York Civil Liberties Union said of the footage: "This video shows precisely why the public deserves to see the circumstances around police shootings. It shows New Yorkers the deadly consequences when unprepared police encounter people in crisis. It is apparent from the footage that these NYPD officers are not equipped to handle people experiencing a mental health crisis. The police department was right to release the video but must now use this opportunity to address its longstanding shortcomings in dealing with people in crisis."
Elin Waring, a sociology professor at Lehman College who has done research on law enforcement, said that while body cameras could be useful, it is still a fairly new technology.
"When you are a researcher you kind of hope that when you are observing a situation that you being there isn't changing the situation," Waring said. "We don't really know whether having body cameras is changing officer behavior or if it is changing public or suspect behavior like that's an open question."
Waring agrees with Commissioner O'Neill that the cameras could help with transparency.


More from News 12
1:38
St. Simon Stock School in Fordham won't reopen this fall due to low enrollment

St. Simon Stock School in Fordham won't reopen this fall due to low enrollment

1:35
Summerlike weather returns to NYC with temps in the 80s; cooler weather for the weekend

Summerlike weather returns to NYC with temps in the 80s; cooler weather for the weekend

1:32
Residents outraged after ban on door cameras at Mott Haven building

Residents outraged after ban on door cameras at Mott Haven building

1:43
Nonprofit wants to bring an independent cinema to the Bronx

Nonprofit wants to bring an independent cinema to the Bronx

Diocese of Brooklyn: 3 Catholic academies to close at the end of the school year

Diocese of Brooklyn: 3 Catholic academies to close at the end of the school year

1:54
Bronx charter schools have open seats for upcoming school year

Bronx charter schools have open seats for upcoming school year

2:04
Grants up for grabs for restaurants hurt by new stove standards

Grants up for grabs for restaurants hurt by new stove standards

1:51
Residents worried that sinkhole problems from years prior may return

Residents worried that sinkhole problems from years prior may return

1:19
Council members making a push for rat birth control

Council members making a push for rat birth control

1:43
NYPD: Multiple suspects wanted for string of gunpoint robberies across the Bronx, Manhattan

NYPD: Multiple suspects wanted for string of gunpoint robberies across the Bronx, Manhattan

1:30
82-unit affordable housing development coming to West Farms

82-unit affordable housing development coming to West Farms

1:51
RFK announces he has enough signatures to appear on NY ballot

RFK announces he has enough signatures to appear on NY ballot

1:41
Bronx man in custody following death of his 79-year-old mother in Concourse Village apartment

Bronx man in custody following death of his 79-year-old mother in Concourse Village apartment

1:47
City officials, drivers weigh in on potential disappearance of parking spots in Mount Hope

City officials, drivers weigh in on potential disappearance of parking spots in Mount Hope

0:34
FBI arrests Brooklyn man in Mount Vernon robbery, homicide

FBI arrests Brooklyn man in Mount Vernon robbery, homicide

2:19
Rent hikes may be coming for tenants in rent-stabilized apartments

Rent hikes may be coming for tenants in rent-stabilized apartments

2:23
Survivors of childhood sexual abuse, community advocates file over 150 lawsuits accusing staff at juvenile facilities

Survivors of childhood sexual abuse, community advocates file over 150 lawsuits accusing staff at juvenile facilities

1:33
NYPD: Man wanted for robbing Mott Haven deli at gunpoint

NYPD: Man wanted for robbing Mott Haven deli at gunpoint

1:57
Pelham Parkway dialysis center closing soon, leaving patients angered

Pelham Parkway dialysis center closing soon, leaving patients angered

2:32
Transportation Alternatives: 2024 was the deadliest start to a year since start of Vision Zero

Transportation Alternatives: 2024 was the deadliest start to a year since start of Vision Zero