Judge orders police to produce 911 tapes in Gilgo case

<p>The family of a woman whose body was found near Gilgo Beach eight years ago is continuing to fight for the release of 911 call tapes relating to the case.</p>

News 12 Staff

Mar 19, 2018, 9:53 PM

Updated 2,229 days ago

Share:

The family of a woman whose body was found near Gilgo Beach eight years ago is continuing to fight for the release of 911 call tapes relating to the case.
After a two-year court battle, the family of Shannan Gilbert has yet to receive the tapes of 911 calls made by Gilbert on the night of her disappearance in May of 2010. Gilbert, a 24-year-old sex worker, was reported missing in 2010 from the Oak Beach home of Joseph Brewer, her last client. Police were searching for her when they found the remains of 10 murder victims along Ocean Parkway.
Police say the official cause of Gilbert's death is "undetermined." But her family believes she was murdered -- and that the 911 tapes may advance their case.
"I'm very frustrated at what has happened because the county has had these tapes since 2011 and they've done nothing whatsoever to advance this case, " says John Ray, the Gilbert family's attorney.
Today, Suffolk police were expected to produce the transcript of the 911 call made by Gilbert in which she reportedly told a 911 operator, "They're trying to kill me."
But the attorney for Suffolk County police told the judge a transcript of the 911 call didn't exist. The judge ordered Suffolk police to turn over the tapes at the next hearing.
Ray says this marks the third time the county has stonewalled on the tapes -- leading him to believe they were tampered with or destroyed under then-Police Chief James Burke.
Burke is serving 35 months in federal prison for beating a handcuffed man in an unrelated case and then covering it up.
"Keep in mind that Chief of Police Burke was in charge of that investigation, almost immediately after, once Shannan Gilbert's body was found," Ray says. "There's a really strong case in my mind that his investigation was hampered, was impeded, and we're going to get to the bottom of it -- slowly but surely, we're going to get to the bottom of it."
The judge has given the attorney for Suffolk police until Monday to produce the tapes in court, or provide an explanation why it can't be done.


More from News 12
1:56
Authorities: 41-year-old man killed by his own dog in Longwood

Authorities: 41-year-old man killed by his own dog in Longwood

0:29
MTA outlines new details on congestion pricing, including start date

MTA outlines new details on congestion pricing, including start date

1:46
Sunny with mild temperatures for New York City today; tracking weekend rain

Sunny with mild temperatures for New York City today; tracking weekend rain

1:46
NYPD: 2nd suspect linked to killing of 17-year-old in Morrisania at large

NYPD: 2nd suspect linked to killing of 17-year-old in Morrisania at large

1:43
See what's happening across the Bronx the weekend of April 27-28

See what's happening across the Bronx the weekend of April 27-28

1:59
6-year-old girl from the Bronx making, selling custom T-shirts for Mother's Day

6-year-old girl from the Bronx making, selling custom T-shirts for Mother's Day

0:29
Where to drop off your prescription drugs safely in the Bronx for National Take Back Day

Where to drop off your prescription drugs safely in the Bronx for National Take Back Day

0:27
Police: Bronx man beaten, stabbed at Showboat Resort Atlantic City; 1 arrested

Police: Bronx man beaten, stabbed at Showboat Resort Atlantic City; 1 arrested

1:55
Tribute held for survivors and victims of high-profile violent Bronx crimes

Tribute held for survivors and victims of high-profile violent Bronx crimes

0:24
Councilmember Marmorato meets with Home Depot staff to discuss security measures

Councilmember Marmorato meets with Home Depot staff to discuss security measures

2:03
Council Member Sanchez introduces building inspection, integrity bills after Billingsley Terrace collapse

Council Member Sanchez introduces building inspection, integrity bills after Billingsley Terrace collapse

1:34
MTA rolls out multibillion-dollar plan to protect transit system from major storms

MTA rolls out multibillion-dollar plan to protect transit system from major storms

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

0:30
Gov. Hochul announces funding to aid flood-prone communities

Gov. Hochul announces funding to aid flood-prone communities

1:35
NYPD: Multiple armed suspects wanted for string of robberies on Bronx train

NYPD: Multiple armed suspects wanted for string of robberies on Bronx train

2:02
Exclusive: Animal rescue group stepping in to help cats in danger of being mauled

Exclusive: Animal rescue group stepping in to help cats in danger of being mauled

0:05
Baseball's oldest living major leaguer, former Yankee Art Schallock, is turning 100

Baseball's oldest living major leaguer, former Yankee Art Schallock, is turning 100

1:54
Bronx Children's Museum offers familiar fun, valuable education for youth and families

Bronx Children's Museum offers familiar fun, valuable education for youth and families

0:19
NYPD: Woman wanted for punching another woman, stealing her phone in Highbridge

NYPD: Woman wanted for punching another woman, stealing her phone in Highbridge

2:07
Council Member Feliz plans to tackle rising vacant storefronts in the Bronx

Council Member Feliz plans to tackle rising vacant storefronts in the Bronx