Rebuilding The Bronx
News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
Taking Action
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Sheepshead Bay HS graduate says ‘Wall of Fame’ plaques were tossed in dumpsters

The school, which was renamed and turned into Frank J. Macchiarola Education Complex, now houses four high schools.

Karina Gerry

Dec 15, 2025, 6:14 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Michael Taylor, a Sheepshead Bay High School graduate, believed his legacy lived on at the school through the Wall of Fame. But last week, he was told by a friend that his and hundred's other's legacies, were thrown in the dumpsters behind the school.

“There’s hundreds of different people over decades that have been honored with their names in the school," said Michael Taylor, a member of the Class of 1988. "The history of Sheepshead Bay High School…was just thrown in the trash.”

The school, which was renamed and turned into Frank J. Macchiarola Education Complex, now houses four high schools.

“Whatever school that was using the area – where these signs are – didn’t want them anymore, and they ripped them off the walls and threw them in the trash," said Taylor.

Sixteen of the plaques are now safely with Taylor.

“At NYCPS, we're proud to honor and celebrate the achievements of current students and our alumni. We're pleased to confirm that the boards have not been removed permanently but are currently being replaced by a digital Wall of Fame that will preserve and display past and present student achievements in a modern, accessible format.”

News 12 reached out to the Board of Education and a spokesperson responded with a written statement:

“At NYCPS, we're proud to honor and celebrate the achievements of current students and our alumni. We're pleased to confirm that the boards have not been removed permanently but are currently being replaced by a digital Wall of Fame that will preserve and display past and present student achievements in a modern, accessible format.”

More Stories

Top Stories

01:06
Screenshot 2026-04-09 053038

Jewelry store robbery leaves windows smashed as suspects flee Perth Amboy

02:16
MARSHALL4

Cold temperatures finally ease as a more tolerable afternoon is expected

00:14
NJ Dance  Mother's day_2026-04-09-08-17-06

Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater returns to NJPAC for Mother's Day weekend

01:17
WoodbridgeShooting

Woodbridge police sergeant indicted in fatal 2025 shooting of man with baseball bat

00:26
Screenshot 2026-04-09 075322

Traffic flowing again after overturned dump truck cleared in Rahway

00:25
Screenshot 2026-04-09 053941

Stunning Milky Way images captured as Artemis II astronauts begin journey home

00:57
Screenshot 2026-04-09 083241

Jack Hughes delights Devils fans at Jersey City meet-and-greet

02:24
Screenshot 2026-04-09 053017

Road Trip Close To Home: Dual elevated indoor tracks debut at K1 Speed bringing high‑speed racing to Passaic County

fatal crash - mon copy (1)

New Jersey man killed in early morning crash in Indiana

02:13
REchristinefwc48_2026-04-08-22-14-21

NJ Transit commuters to be blocked from trains on FIFA game days

01:10
MTNJNuclear0408_2026-04-08-22-32-30

Onward to the future: Gov. Sherrill signs nuclear power bill for New Jersey

01:20
REMontclairtrashsnow48_2026-04-08-22-16-44

Trash-filled snowbanks remain in Montclair parks months after blizzard

00:58
MTNJJerseyProud0408_2026-04-08-22-33-13

Jersey Proud: Six NJ schools to attend American Rocketry Challenge finals

01:44
REMorristwplawsuit48_2026-04-08-17-23-27

Morris Township targeted with a lawsuit by the Trump administration

02:47
LI 5PM WED_RexNuts&Bolts_ajc_2026-04-08-17-08-10

‘Sadistic, soulless, murderous monster.’ 'Gilgo Beach' serial killer Rex Heuermann pleads guilty to 8 killings on Long Island ending decadelong case

14:29
rex still

LIVE COVERAGE: Rex Heuermann pleads guilty to Gilgo Beach serial killings, admits responsibility to eighth slaying

02:01
REJenniwc48_2026-04-08-17-26-02

Rutherford police prepare for the FIFA World Cup 2026

01:17
WoodbridgeShooting

Woodbridge police sergeant indicted in fatal 2025 shooting of man with baseball bat

00:19
f15d9f30-181e-4e51-89b7-6e5b510b3992

Camden County high school teacher had sexual relationship with student, prosecutor says

GenericPOLICE

Hammonton police sergeant indicted, allegedly stole drugs from evidence room 

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices