Supreme Court could strike down law that restricts NYers from carrying gun in public for self-defense

The high court could strike down a law that restricts people from carrying concealed handguns outside the home for self-defense.

News 12 Staff

Nov 4, 2021, 10:04 AM

Updated 951 days ago

Share:

New York’s tough gun laws are in the crosshairs of the Supreme Court.
The high court could strike down a law that restricts people from carrying concealed handguns outside the home for self-defense.
On Wednesday, the court was hearing arguments in its biggest guns case in more than a decade, a dispute over whether New York's law violates the Second Amendment right to “keep and bear arms.”
Chief Justice John Roberts and other conservative members of the court, which has a 6-3 conservative majority, suggested New York's law goes too far. Why, Roberts asked, does a person seeking a license to carry a gun in public for self-defense have to show a special need to do so? “The idea that you would need a license to exercise a right is unusual with regard to the Bill of Rights,” he said.
But Roberts was also among the justices who pressed a lawyer for the law's challengers on where guns might be prohibited.
Paul Clement, arguing on behalf of New York residents who want an unrestricted right to carry concealed weapons in public, replied that while government buildings and schools might be off limits, bars “might be a tougher case for the government.”
The court's liberals seemed willing to allow the state law to remain in place, especially focusing on differences between rural areas and more densely populated cities and suburbs.
The law's defenders have said that striking it down will lead to more guns on the streets of cities including New York and Los Angeles.
The court last issued major gun rights decisions in 2008 and 2010.
Those decisions established a nationwide right to keep a gun at home for self-defense.
The question for the court now has to do with carrying a gun in public for self-defense.
AP wires contributed to this report.


More from News 12
1:28
NYPD: 37-year-old woman from Mount Vernon fatally slashed in the neck in Williamsbridge; suspect arrested

NYPD: 37-year-old woman from Mount Vernon fatally slashed in the neck in Williamsbridge; suspect arrested

2:08
Mostly sunny and pleasant weather; tracking strong to severe thunderstorms for the Bronx

Mostly sunny and pleasant weather; tracking strong to severe thunderstorms for the Bronx

1:52
Bronx school watches USA vs. India in New York’s final Cricket World Cup match

Bronx school watches USA vs. India in New York’s final Cricket World Cup match

1:45
Morris Park community demands end to gun violence following death of 29-year-old man

Morris Park community demands end to gun violence following death of 29-year-old man

0:51
Health fair in the Bronx spotlights needs of LGBTQ+ community

Health fair in the Bronx spotlights needs of LGBTQ+ community

1:53
Police: 4 men use hammers, axes to steal 30 pairs of designer glasses in Co-op City

Police: 4 men use hammers, axes to steal 30 pairs of designer glasses in Co-op City

1:41
P.S. 100X students bring home the Mayor Dinkins Cup

P.S. 100X students bring home the Mayor Dinkins Cup

0:24
NYPD: Man fatally struck by car while walking across the Washington Bridge

NYPD: Man fatally struck by car while walking across the Washington Bridge

2:15
New York launches Mobile ID to digitize driver’s licenses, non-driver IDs. Here’s how to get it.

New York launches Mobile ID to digitize driver’s licenses, non-driver IDs. Here’s how to get it.

1:28
Garden Guide: This is why your plants are blooming better than usual this year

Garden Guide: This is why your plants are blooming better than usual this year

1:28
Light installation celebrating the Bronx community glows in Morris Park

Light installation celebrating the Bronx community glows in Morris Park

2:05
Community members split on additional protection of bike lanes along Park Avenue

Community members split on additional protection of bike lanes along Park Avenue

1:51
Bronx man says MTA is charging him for tolls on trips he didn’t take

Bronx man says MTA is charging him for tolls on trips he didn’t take

2:12
Casa Celina – new affordable housing for seniors opens in Soundview

Casa Celina – new affordable housing for seniors opens in Soundview

0:37
Dog fight! Joey Chestnut out of July 4 hot dog eating contest due to deal with rival brand

Dog fight! Joey Chestnut out of July 4 hot dog eating contest due to deal with rival brand

21:13
Kane In Your Corner: Victims of the System

Kane In Your Corner: Victims of the System

1:29
What’s a heat dome? Here’s what to expect when it arrives next week

What’s a heat dome? Here’s what to expect when it arrives next week

2:07
Baychester residents outraged after months of overflowing garbage

Baychester residents outraged after months of overflowing garbage

1:45
New York Philharmonic concert series returns with first stop at Van Cortlandt Park tonight

New York Philharmonic concert series returns with first stop at Van Cortlandt Park tonight

1:21
NYPD: 3 injured in shooting near Belmont park

NYPD: 3 injured in shooting near Belmont park