Opposite sides demonstrate in Riverdale over proposal to house migrants in former Manhattan College dorm

One side of the street chanted comments like "go back to your country" and the other side yelled "immigrants are welcome here."

Greg Thompson and Natalie Hernandez

Sep 24, 2023, 10:03 PM

Updated 211 days ago

Share:

Community members joined together on Sunday in two separate protests in Riverdale debating the future of a building that was once owned by Manhattan College.
One side of the street chanted comments like "go back to your country" and the other side yelled "immigrants are welcome here."
The school told News 12 they sold the building in May to a company called The Stagg Group, which had told the community they planned to turn it into affordable housing. Instead, as first reported by the Riverdale Press, Stagg announced at a community board meeting two weeks ago that they're now talking to the city about using it to house immigrants.
"Our local Americans who need affordable housing - that's what this dorm should be for. It shouldn't be a money grab," said one Riverdale resident named Mitch. "Manhattan College sold us out and now they destroyed their very own community."
Members of that same community on the other side of the street, however, said they didn't see an issue. Resident Namoi Sharlin and another neighbor said, "If the company wants to use this building as temporary housing for migrants, I say good on that company. 'Wow, you're really doing something good."
Bridget McEvoy, who also lives in Riverdale, said she came out to support the immigrants.
"It doesn't seem like they're protesting the company across the street. It seems like they're protesting migrants, and that's the problem I have," she said.
But some in that group, with Guardian Angels founder and former mayoral candidate Curtis Sliwa leading the way, argued that they don't have a problem with immigrants. He said they just believe veterans and homeless people already in America should be the priority.
Sharlin disagrees though.
"I don't think it's either or. I think that's a scarcity mindset. We can house immigrants and we can have affordable housing," Sharlin said.
Nothing has been officially set in stone for the building's future so far. The city would have to sign off on any plan to use it as immigrant housing, and there's no timetable for when that might happen.
News 12 reached out to The Stagg Group for comment but had not heard back as of Sunday night.


More from News 12
DA: 3 teens indicted for killing bystander, wounding 4 in subway shooting

DA: 3 teens indicted for killing bystander, wounding 4 in subway shooting

1:49
Scattered showers across Wednesday; colder weather arrives Thursday

Scattered showers across Wednesday; colder weather arrives Thursday

1:15
State taxi federation raises reward for information to help stop carjackings, robberies

State taxi federation raises reward for information to help stop carjackings, robberies

1:42
Irish consulate general joins BP Gibson for a Woodlawn walkthrough

Irish consulate general joins BP Gibson for a Woodlawn walkthrough

1:00
Fordham Road BID discusses local improvements made, offers a look toward the future

Fordham Road BID discusses local improvements made, offers a look toward the future

1:56
MTA meets with riders in Fordham to hear their concerns with current transit system

MTA meets with riders in Fordham to hear their concerns with current transit system

0:59
City now has power to padlock illegal cannabis stores

City now has power to padlock illegal cannabis stores

1:30
NYPD: Shooting suspect linked to death of 24-year-old in Melrose still on the loose

NYPD: Shooting suspect linked to death of 24-year-old in Melrose still on the loose

0:30
Bronx hip-hop star MC Sha-Rock, Bronx Historical Society offering $1,000 scholarship

Bronx hip-hop star MC Sha-Rock, Bronx Historical Society offering $1,000 scholarship

1:44
'I can sleep better.' Longwood resident thanks News 12 for report on Bruckner Expressway construction noise

'I can sleep better.' Longwood resident thanks News 12 for report on Bruckner Expressway construction noise

1:20
Police: $1,000 stolen from Bronx gas station at gunpoint; suspects at large

Police: $1,000 stolen from Bronx gas station at gunpoint; suspects at large

State police: Victim of I-684 car crash identified as convicted murderer in country illegally

State police: Victim of I-684 car crash identified as convicted murderer in country illegally

2:50
Residents in Morris Heights living in ‘uninhabitable’ conditions demand fair housing

Residents in Morris Heights living in ‘uninhabitable’ conditions demand fair housing

1:34
'We really want to find him.' Wakefield family searches for missing loved one

'We really want to find him.' Wakefield family searches for missing loved one

0:45
New York Botanical Garden celebrates Earth Day

New York Botanical Garden celebrates Earth Day

1:27
Scholar Athlete: Tiarra Jackson

Scholar Athlete: Tiarra Jackson

1:49
Spring break in the Bronx: Low-cost events and activities around the borough

Spring break in the Bronx: Low-cost events and activities around the borough

1:43
Jamie Towers residents rally against increased rent, citing unsanitary conditions

Jamie Towers residents rally against increased rent, citing unsanitary conditions

0:27
Sanitation workers to collect trash earlier to speed up cleaning NYC streets

Sanitation workers to collect trash earlier to speed up cleaning NYC streets

0:30
Police: Bronx commuter wanted for spraying MTA employee in the face with 'an unknown substance'

Police: Bronx commuter wanted for spraying MTA employee in the face with 'an unknown substance'