Sayville residents against self-storage company setting up shop in community

Safgeguard wants to put a $10 million facility at the former athletic complex F 14 Sports, but it has sparked a zoning fight between area businesses and the developer.

News 12 Staff

Sep 30, 2021, 7:20 PM

Updated 936 days ago

Share:

A self-storage company is looking at Sayville for its next location, but many residents in the village tell News 12 they feel it's going to ruin their community.
Safgeguard wants to put a $10 million facility at the former athletic complex F 14 Sports, but it has sparked a zoning fight between area businesses and the developer. To put the facility there, the Town of Islip would need to change the zoning from a business zone to an industrial zone.
The matter was considered at a meeting Thursday, but no decision was made.
The Sayville Chamber of Commerce, local businesses and some nearby residents are vehemently against the idea, saying, a self-storage facility would encroach on the look and feel of the village’s Main Street and not bring in any foot traffic or revenue to nearby businesses.
"It is not a good project for our community," said Eileen Tyznar, a member of Sayville’s Chamber of Commerce. "Doesn't fit. The next person is gonna want a vape shop or wants an adult shop or wants anything else they can challenge and ask why can we not have a zone change. It's a slippery slope."
"I would have to drive through it every day," added Matthew Juvet, a Sayville resident. "There's gonna be 24 hour lights and people coming and going." 
Stanley Bonilla, SVP of Safeguard, says architects have designed the building to fit in with area homes, and pledges he wants to work with the community. 
"My goal always is to be the best neighbor we can possibly be because it the neighbors who we are serving," said Bonilla.


More from News 12
1:30
NYPD: Shooting suspect linked to death of 24-year-old in Melrose still on the loose

NYPD: Shooting suspect linked to death of 24-year-old in Melrose still on the loose

0:30
Bronx hip-hop star MC Sha-Rock, Bronx Historical Society offering $1,000 scholarship

Bronx hip-hop star MC Sha-Rock, Bronx Historical Society offering $1,000 scholarship

1:49
Scattered showers across Wednesday; colder weather arrives Thursday

Scattered showers across Wednesday; colder weather arrives Thursday

1:44
'I can sleep better.' Longwood resident thanks News 12 for report on Bruckner Expressway construction noise

'I can sleep better.' Longwood resident thanks News 12 for report on Bruckner Expressway construction noise

0:27
Police: $1,000 stolen from Bronx gas station at gunpoint; suspects at large

Police: $1,000 stolen from Bronx gas station at gunpoint; suspects at large

State police: Victim of I-684 car crash identified as convicted murderer in country illegally

State police: Victim of I-684 car crash identified as convicted murderer in country illegally

2:50
Residents in Morris Heights living in ‘uninhabitable’ conditions demand fair housing

Residents in Morris Heights living in ‘uninhabitable’ conditions demand fair housing

1:34
'We really want to find him.' Wakefield family searches for missing loved one

'We really want to find him.' Wakefield family searches for missing loved one

0:45
New York Botanical Garden celebrates Earth Day

New York Botanical Garden celebrates Earth Day

1:27
Scholar Athlete: Tiarra Jackson

Scholar Athlete: Tiarra Jackson

1:49
Spring break in the Bronx: Low-cost events and activities around the borough

Spring break in the Bronx: Low-cost events and activities around the borough

1:43
Jamie Towers residents rally against increased rent, citing unsanitary conditions

Jamie Towers residents rally against increased rent, citing unsanitary conditions

0:27
Sanitation workers to collect trash earlier to speed up cleaning NYC streets

Sanitation workers to collect trash earlier to speed up cleaning NYC streets

0:30
Police: Bronx commuter wanted for spraying MTA employee in the face with 'an unknown substance'

Police: Bronx commuter wanted for spraying MTA employee in the face with 'an unknown substance'

1:40
Bronx's Oyate Group, Grubhub and NYS Latino Restaurant Association team up for restaurant business boost

Bronx's Oyate Group, Grubhub and NYS Latino Restaurant Association team up for restaurant business boost

1:44
Estella Diggs honored with street sign unveiling in Morrisania

Estella Diggs honored with street sign unveiling in Morrisania

0:36
Yonkers native Mary J. Blige, Queens hip-hop group A Tribe Called Quest selected for Rock Hall of Fame

Yonkers native Mary J. Blige, Queens hip-hop group A Tribe Called Quest selected for Rock Hall of Fame

0:59
NYPD: Suspect wanted for shooting 18-year-old in Belmont

NYPD: Suspect wanted for shooting 18-year-old in Belmont

1:56
Passover preparation underway for members of Chabad Lubavitch of Riverdale

Passover preparation underway for members of Chabad Lubavitch of Riverdale