Temple congregants disturbed by shots from NYPD range

Congregants at Temple Beth-El on City Island Avenue were upset after their request that an NYPD shooting range cease detonations on Yom Kippur were unheard. Those who attend services at the Bronx temple

News 12 Staff

Nov 19, 2016, 6:00 AM

Updated 2,703 days ago

Share:

Temple congregants disturbed by shots from NYPD range
Congregants at Temple Beth-El on City Island Avenue were upset after their request that an NYPD shooting range cease detonations on Yom Kippur were unheard.
Those who attend services at the Bronx temple say that normally they have learned to manage and even ignore the sound of gunshots from the firing range at Rodman's Neck.
Robert Berent, a member of Temple Beth-El for about 50 years, says the congregation learned that the NYPD training facility was going to detonate explosives on the holiest day of the Jewish year and that temple leaders sent a letter to various city agencies asking for a delay to the detonations so they could reflect in peace. He says they never received a response. 
Berent says that three explosive devices were detonated on Yom Kippur, which interrupted their services twice.
John Doyle, of the City Island Civic Association, says it's just another example of the nuisance caused by all the noise that comes from Rodman's Neck. 
"When they were talking about moving this to Queens, they were going to totally enclose this range because they knew the residents of Queens would not put up with this," Doyle says. "But for some reason they feel the need to dump on the Bronx and not afford us the same opportunity."
Doyle has started a petition on Change.org, calling on elected officials to come forward with what they're doing to combat the commotion. He says that this will get an open and transparent process going that will eventually benefit everyone.
News 12 reached out to the mayor's office for comment but has not heard back.


More from News 12
0:43
NYPD: Victims identified, arrest made in fatal Fordham crash that killed 2

NYPD: Victims identified, arrest made in fatal Fordham crash that killed 2

1:22
STORM WATCH: Cloudy skies and a scattered thunderstorm tonight in New York City

STORM WATCH: Cloudy skies and a scattered thunderstorm tonight in New York City

1:27
NYPD deploys resources to places of worship amid increased Middle East tensions

NYPD deploys resources to places of worship amid increased Middle East tensions

0:28
Israel hails ‘success’ in blocking Iran’s unprecedented attack. Biden now seeks diplomatic response

Israel hails ‘success’ in blocking Iran’s unprecedented attack. Biden now seeks diplomatic response

1:27
Lickety Split Ice Cream in City Island to mark 20 years in business

Lickety Split Ice Cream in City Island to mark 20 years in business

0:35
2 men arrested, accused in Fordham jewelry store armed robbery

2 men arrested, accused in Fordham jewelry store armed robbery

0:58
Police: 3 New York City residents arrested for organized retail theft at New Jersey mall

Police: 3 New York City residents arrested for organized retail theft at New Jersey mall

MTA police: Man punched 9-year-old girl in face at Grand Central Terminal

MTA police: Man punched 9-year-old girl in face at Grand Central Terminal

1:41
Street vendors on Fordham Road say rise in summonses is making it difficult to make a living

Street vendors on Fordham Road say rise in summonses is making it difficult to make a living

1:32
NYPD: Crash in Fordham leaves 2 men dead

NYPD: Crash in Fordham leaves 2 men dead

0:32
NYPD: 3 suspects wanted for armed taxi robbery in Clason Point

NYPD: 3 suspects wanted for armed taxi robbery in Clason Point

1:39
What you need to know about this weekend's L train closure

What you need to know about this weekend's L train closure

0:22
Police: 14-year-old girl from Soundview reported missing

Police: 14-year-old girl from Soundview reported missing

1:38
Community baby shower in Brownsville aims to help underprivileged moms

Community baby shower in Brownsville aims to help underprivileged moms

1:35
CDC: Measles could lose 'elimination status' amid uptick across the U.S.

CDC: Measles could lose 'elimination status' amid uptick across the U.S.

2:12
Family in mourning after loved one fatally struck by car in Concourse Village hit-and-run

Family in mourning after loved one fatally struck by car in Concourse Village hit-and-run

0:50
NYPD commissioner: Officers who shot and killed Kawaski Trawick did not commit a crime

NYPD commissioner: Officers who shot and killed Kawaski Trawick did not commit a crime

0:44
Bronx mother indicted on murder, manslaughter charges in death of twins in Mount Hope

Bronx mother indicted on murder, manslaughter charges in death of twins in Mount Hope

1:53
Community members worry for safety of pets, children over used needles scattered across South Bronx park

Community members worry for safety of pets, children over used needles scattered across South Bronx park

1:15
Garifuna culture showcase takes over the Bronx this Saturday

Garifuna culture showcase takes over the Bronx this Saturday